Best Ice Fishing Suits Reviews & Buying Guide 2021

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest

When the winter strikes, anglers start to drill holes in the ice. Thus, marking the beginning of the ice fishing season. But catching fish in these harsh environments takes more than a rod and line. You require special gear to cope with such conditions. 

An ice fishing suit is among those special pieces of gear you need. Here we present you with 10 of the best options you can find in the market. However, we know that not everyone has the time to read the entire article. So, here are our picks.

The WindRider Ice Fishing Suit is our favorite one. It offers insulation, water protection, and flotation assistance. It also has plenty of pockets to keep some gear close, and the overall construction is very breathable. On the other hand, the Simms Men’s Challenger is a superb option for those willing to pay for it. It has a 100% nylon shell that keeps the water out, retains heat while allowing moisture to escape. But if you are looking for something affordable, then the Frogg Toggs All-Sport is your best bet. 

Let’s take a look at the others.

10 Best Ice Fishing Suits Reviewed

WindRider Ice Fishing Suit

Features: 

  • Sizes available: From X-Small to 3X-Large
  • 3M Foam insulation
  • Removable insulated hood
  • Double storm flaps
  • Adjustable shoulder straps and inseam 

With a hefty price tag, the WindRider ice fishing suit is among the best premium models you can get. While it is bulky, there is a reason for it. Both the jacket and bibs feature a foam layer that not only keeps you warm. But increase your buoyancy as well. Something that will come in handy if you ever fall while ice fishing. 

Both the jacket and bibs use the same durable, water-resistant fabric for the outer shell. WindRider also reinforced the knees and elbows to ensure a long-lasting operation. 

The suit has lots of pockets. The jacket has two zippered pockets at chest height. They are ideal for keeping your phone close. The lower pockets have enough insulation to warm your hands while you wait for a bite. The ice fishing wader has its share of openings as well. 

The bibs come with adjustable shoulder straps and inseam. Thus, allowing a tighter fit, which increases thermal performance. 

Pros: 

  • It floats 
  • The suit has lots of pockets 
  • Reinforced knees and elbows 
  • Very warm yet breathable

Cons: 

  • Heavy
  • Sizes run small
  • The waist strap is not that durable

Simms Challenger Insulated Jacket and Bibs

Features: 

  • Sizes available: From Small to 4X-Large
  • 100% nylon construction
  • Reinforced knees
  • Fully adjustable
  • Zippered pockets 

Last but not least, it is time to review the Simms Challenger ice fishing suit. It is available in several sizes. Sadly, it is only available in one color. 

The entire ice fishing suit comprises two layers of Toray fabric with one extra layer of insulation. Allegedly, it keeps you warm no matter what. Thankfully, it is true. The hood, high collar, adjustable cuffs, and ankle straps improve heat retention, which is crucial for ice fishing. 

Another thing that we loved was the lack of bulk. The Simms ice fishing suit is pleasantly slim, allowing a much more natural movement. 

The lack of pockets is the main drawback. You only get six: Two on the jacket and the others in the bibs. Only the ones in the pants are large enough to accommodate some tools.

The bibs come with zippered legs. You can open them for better heat management. However, this isn’t useful for ice fishing purposes. 

Pros: 

  • Great value of your money
  • Light and comfortable
  • Flexible 
  • Reinforced knees and elbows
  • Durable zipper

Cons: 

  • The pants are very loose
  • Poor heat retention if you don’t adjust the suit tightly
  • Small pockets

Frogg Toggs Men’s Classic Waterproof Suit

Features: 

  • Sizes available: From small to 3X-Large
  • Polyester construction 
  • Waterproof membrane
  • Removable hood
  • Washing machine compatible
  • Snap-down flap 

Although it doesn’t offer much insulation, the Frogg Toggs ice fishing suit makes its way to this review thanks to its affordable price tag. 

The 100% polypropylene paired with a waterproof layer provides wind and water resistance. But it also helps to keep the weight down. A feature that some people might value a lot. 

You can fully adjust the pants thanks to the customizable leg openings and elastic waist. Like the jacket, the lower section is also water and windproof. Sadly, you don’t get reinforced knees or many pockets for storage. However, at this price point, you can hardly complain. 

As we said before, the entire ice fishing suit is remarkably light. Sadly, Frogg Toggs achieve this at the expense of insulation. 

Pros: 

  • Lightweight
  • Many colors and sizes are available
  • Comfortable to wear
  • May different sizes available

Cons: 

  • It doesn’t offer much insulation
  • Not enough pockets 

StrikerIce Men’s Ice Fishing Jacket

Features: 

  • Sizes available: From Small to 5X-Large
  • Nylon and polyester construction
  • Waterproof zippers 
  • Flotation system
  • Removable soft jacket and hood
  • Water and windproof shell 

Although we are missing the ice fishing bibs, this jacket is something else. It has a removable G2 softshell jacket for increased warmth and water protection. Both the inner and outer jackets have nylon and polyester construction. Although it is heavy, you can wash it on any washing machine. The waterproof zippers, reflective elements, and cross-flow venting system are durable enough to handle the strain.

StrikerIce added their proprietary 150g Sureflote technology. Allegedly, it is capable of keeping the wearer afloat for up to 2 hours. Plenty of time to get out of the icy water if you happen to fall. 

All that is left is to pair the jacket with a decent ice fishing bib like the StrikerIce Climate. The combo is expensive. But you will have a long-lasting ice fishing suit that you can take virtually anywhere. 

Pros: 

  • Machine washable
  • Removable hood
  • Warm yet breathable
  • Removable softshell jacket

Cons:

  • The bibs are sold separately
  • A little bulkier than the average
  • Not suitable for small anglers 

Eskimo Men’s Legend Ice Fishing Suit

Features: 

  • Sizes available: From medium to 5X-Large
  • Polyester shell with 500 denier nylon reinforcements 
  • Waterproof zippers 
  • Removable hood
  • DWR treatment
  • Quick-dry system

Our main complaint is that the bib and jacket come separately. Nevertheless, it is a great combo that packs quality. 

Let’s talk about the jacket first. It has a polyester fabric layer with a DWR coating and a 10k/10k waterproof/breathability rating. In other words, the coat is warm but breathable, and it keeps water at bay as well.

The body has 100gm of 3M insulation, which is more than enough for keeping the weight manageable. To avoid overbulk, Eskimo cut the insulation to 60gm on the sleeves. Thus, allowing a much more natural movement. 

The jacket lacks the pocket count of other models. Still, it is more than enough room for the average angler. 

The bibs have a similar construction in terms of materials. The remarkable feature here is that Eskimo reinforced the knees with a 500 denier nylon layer. On the other hand, the adjustable shoulder strap and waistband ensure a tight fit. 

Pros: 

  • Suitable for big anglers 
  • Durable fabric 
  • Reinforced elbows and knees
  • The arms are less bulky than the average

Cons: 

  • Bibs and jackets sold separately
  • There are no small sizes available 
  • Some zippers get stuck

iCreek Rain Suit 

Features: 

  • Sizes available: From small to 5X-Large
  • Nano polyester 240T construction
  • Waterproof 
  • Protective mask
  • Breathable

iCreek rain suit is another option for those with a tight budget. It is available in several different colors and sizes. The high-tech nano polyester is 100% waterproof and breathable. Plus, since it lacks insulation, it is also pleasantly light.

The double zipper system is waterproof. But it also seals the interior and keeps you fairly warm. On the other hand, the high collar and hood protect your neck and head while keeping water out. The back has built-in flow holes that promote air circulation. 

All pockets are waterproof and large enough to accommodate some gear. However, they lack zippers. So, keep an eye on your gear.

The suit comes with a transparent mask. It will protect your face from water splashes as well as ice. 

Still, the iCreek doesn’t offer much insulation. Thus, it might not be the best option for those without an ice fishing shelter. 

Pros: 

  • Light and compact
  • Comfortable 
  • Adjustable velcro straps offer a tight fit 

Cons: 

  • Poor insulation
  • Runs small

Navis Marine Offshore Ice Fishing Jacket and Bibs

Features: 

  • Sizes available: From small to 2X-Large
  • 90% nylon and 10% PTFE composite construction
  • Reflective straps 
  • Adjustable shoulder, waist, and ankle straps 

Versatile and fashionable are two words we would use to describe the Navis Marine Offshore ice fishing suit. The entire outfit is 90% nylon and 10% PTFE. Thus, it is waterproof. It also provides some degree of insulation thanks to the mesh warm lining. It is ideal for early winter fishing. But it might not be enough for freezing conditions.

The jacket has four pockets at the front and one on each sleeve. All of them are waterproof. Sadly, the zippers on the pockets get stuck at times. So, have a little patience with them. In contrast, the two velcro pockets work like a charm. They are easy to open and remain closed at all times. 

You can fully adjust the bibs thanks to the shoulder and waist straps. The velcro ankle bands keep the water out while also enhancing heat retention. 

Pros: 

  • Versatile 
  • Impressive water and wind protection
  • It has reflective straps 
  • Fully adjustable suit

Cons: 

  • Sizes run small
  • The hood is rather uncomfortable 

Frabill I2 Ice Fishing Suit

Features: 

  • Sizes available: 2X-Large
  • 300 denier nylon shell
  • Self-rescue system
  • 150 g of 3M Thinsulate insulation
  • Reflective materials
  • Adjustable shoulders 

The first thing that stands out on this ice fishing suit is the built-in self-rescue system. You can activate it to increase buoyancy if you happen to fall. 

The jacket and bibs have a waterproof and breathable 300 denier nylon shell. In addition, the coat has 150 grams of 3M Thinsulate covering that keeps you warm at all times without being bulky. One thing that we missed was more pockets. The jacket only has two, and both are small. The zipper closure system works great and it doesn’t get stuck. However, this is something to expect given the price tag.

The bibs, on the other hand, come with reinforced knees with two large pockets. The downside is that it only comes with an adjustable shoulder strap. We don’t get the same for the ankles or waist. Thus, it doesn’t fit as tightly as other models, which is a good thing if you plan to use thick clothes underneath. 

Pros:

  • Self-rescue system
  • Quick-dry
  • Reinforced knees 
  • Durable shell

Cons: 

  • Loose fit 
  • The pants are warmer than the jacket
  • Single size available 

Stormr Men’s Strykr Ice Fishing Jacket

Features: 

  • Sizes available: From small to 3X-Large
  • Neoprene construction
  • Large pockets 
  • Non-corrosion zippers 

Although expensive, the STRYKR ice fishing jacket is a superb choice for those looking for incredible protection and insulation. It is available in several sizes, ranging from small to 3X-Large. Plus, you can choose between four unique designs. 

Sadly, as you might notice, it doesn’t come with the bibs. Still, you can get the ice fishing bibs separately. 

The jacket has a water-resistant, windproof neoprene exterior. It remains flexible so you can move without worrying too much. Plus, the built-in pockets are water-tight, which means that your phone will remain dry.

The adjustable cuffs, hood, and high collar help with heat retention. The bibs, on the other hand, have the same neoprene build. Sadly, they only have adjustable shoulder straps. Don’t expect a tight fit.  

Our main complaint is that the bids X-large and jackets come separately. According to STORMR, this helps you to find the perfect size for you. 

Pros: 

  • Impressive heat retention
  • Flexible
  • Durable pants
  • Suitable for ice fishing and heavy rain
  • The bibs come with large pockets 

Cons: 

  • The jacket and pants are sold separately 
  • It is not that breathable

WindRider Pro Foul Weather Gear

Features: 

  • Sizes available: From Small to 3X-Large
  • Nylon and polyester construction
  • Reflective logo
  • Reinforced knees 
  • Lots of pockets 
  • Fully adjustable suit

Rain, snow, or ice, the Pro Foul weather suit will protect you from all harm. You can choose between black and red models and sizes up to 3X-large. So you can be certain that you will find the one suit. 

The exterior is breathable yet water and windproof. The long zipper and internal soft cuffs help to seal the interior tight. Thus, offering some degree of insulation, which is enough to keep you warm in early winter. But it might be of little use in tougher conditions. 

You can’t remove the hood. Still, you can roll and tuck it away. The reflective WindRider logo increases visibility in the dark. A crucial feature when fishing on the ice at night. 

The ice fishing bibs come with Cordura reinforced knees and plenty of pockets. The zippered fleece chest pockets come with a hand-warmer lining. Sadly, we’ve noticed that zippers don’t look as durable as the ones on other models. On the other hand, the velcro adjustable shoulder straps and ankle adjusters help to keep the pants in place. 

Pros: 

  • Multiple storage options
  • Light and breathable 
  • Adjustable cuff, shoulder straps, ankle adjusters 
  • Reinforced knees

Cons: 

  • Not enough insulation for freezing conditions 
  • You can’t remove the hood

What to Look for When Buying Ice Fishing Suits

Ideally, the best ice fishing suit needs to be durable to cope with the abuse. Have enough insulation to keep you warm and remain breathable enough to prevent moisture buildup. Sadly, this usually brings some problems.

For example, a warm and durable ice fishing suit is inherently more expensive and heavier. Thus, it is a question of what you need and what you are willing to let go of.

Here we will take some time to understand each feature and its impact on performance. This way, you can make the right decisions. Let’s get started. 

Insulation

Insulation is the first that comes into mind when thinking about an ice fishing suit. After all, we will be fishing in freezing temperatures. Thus, it is logical to think about protecting ourselves against cold. 

Most ice fishing suits feature insulation layers like the 3M Thinsulate synthetic fabric. But, if two suits have the same layer, how do I know which is warmer? 

Well, brands usually show how many grams they add. So, the more grams, the hotter the suit gets. Sadly, this also means it gets heavier as well. 

More insulation also tempers with movement. So, if you are looking to get something versatile, then you should avoid ice fishing suits with lots of insulation. 

As a countermeasure, some brands use less insulation in the arms and more in the body. This way, they offer somewhat the same warmth without compromising movement. 

Try your best to find an ice fishing suit with a meshed interior. The heat management will be much better, thus, preventing moisture buildup. 

Waterproofing Capabilities

Insulation only helps as much. Nothing will save you from freezing if the suit ever gets soaked with water. That’s why it is crucial to get a model with a reliable DWR layer. 

Some brands use a water-resistant treatment to keep the water out. Others add PVC or polyurethane layers. The second is more long-lasting. But the first is typically cheaper. Plus, you can always re-apply for the treatment coating after some time.

Keep in mind one thing. Regardless of which approach you like, the suit must remain breathable enough to allow moisture to escape. Otherwise, you will start to sweat, and it will dip your clothes. 

That’s why it is also equally important to get an ice fishing suit with ankle and cuff adjusters. This way, you can seal any entry point.  

Pockets

While it is not a necessity, having pockets on your ice fishing suit is an advantage. You can keep multitools, line cutters, GPS, and even your phone within reach. Naturally, keep any sensitive electronics inside a waterproof pocket. Some pockets also act as hand warmers. 

Most pockets either use a zipper or button buckle as closure systems. The first is better for small or delicate pieces of gear. 

Ice Fishing Suit Construction

Neoprene, polyester, and nylon are the most common materials used. Some models even mix them, creating a much more versatile suit. 

As we said before, some brands add polyurethane and PVC layers embedded within the shell as well. This way, they can enhance water resistance without increasing bulk. 

Reinforced Knees and Elbows 

Many people often overlook this feature. But think. How many times do you kneel on a single ice fishing trip? Many, right? And you do it on rough ground. So, it is not a surprise to notice that the fabric in those areas tends to wear out quicker. 

That’s why it pays to get ice fishing bibs with reinforced knees. If possible, with reinforced elbows too. 

Aim for Cordura reinforcements, as it is the most durable of them all. 

Fit and Size

Measure your chest, waist, arms, inseams, and legs. It is the only way you will find the size that best suits you. Remember that sizes are not standard between brands. Therefore, you must always check the size chart first before making any decision. 

One thing that you must keep in mind is extra clothes. If you are planning on using thick clothes or wearing more than one shirt, you should consider going a little larger. This way, you won’t feel cramped as soon as you put the suit on. 

Buoyancy 

Although not all ice fishing suits have flotation assistance, it is a life-saving feature that you should consider. 

Some brands add foam within the suit to increase buoyancy. Others, on the other hand, add an external flotation device. It is up to you which one is the best. In our opinion, the first approach is better. 

We highly suggest getting an ice fishing suit with flotation assistance. It will be easier to get out of the freezing water if you happen to fall. Why? Well, the suit not only floats. But it won’t weigh you down as soon as it gets soaked with water. So, a win-win scenario.  

Reflective Straps

Like flotation assistance, reflective straps are often overlooked features in ice fishing suits. And the truth is that it shouldn’t, especially if you are planning on fishing at night. Besides, some local laws compel you to use reflective clothing. 

Ice Fishing Suit FAQ

Do I Really Need an Ice Fishing Suit?

You can, by all means, fish on the ice without an ice fishing suit. But we highly recommend getting one. It will keep your body warm and dry during the session. Plus, it will keep you afloat if you happen to fall, making the difference in a life and death situation. 

What Should I Wear Beneath an Ice Fishing Suit? 

Fleece pants, hoodies, and thick shirts will do the trick. 

What’s More Important, the Bibs or the Jacket?

It largely depends on your needs. For instance, the ice fishing jacket might be enough for some people. For others, the bibs are just what they need to cope with freezing conditions. 

Either way, we suggest getting both. You can always remove the jacket if things get too warm. But you can put it on if you don’t have one. 

Ice Fishing Suit: Closing Thoughts 

When it comes down to choosing the best ice fishing suit, we have no doubts. It is the WindRider Ice Fishing Suit. First, it has a long-lasting build. The zippers won’t get stuck, as happens with other models. Plus, it comes with reinforced knees and elbows. So, don’t worry if you need to kneel on gravel, ice, or rocks. 

In addition, the ice fishing suit packs a foam layer that increases buoyancy. So, it will be easier to get out of the icy water if you ever fall. 

You also get lots of pockets, which is always a must for anglers. And on top of all, the suit looks good. So, it is one hell of a deal. You can get yours here.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

ABOUT ME

Hi! I’m Steven!

I am an avid life long fisherman, having caught over 25,000 fish over the years. My life-long passion for fishing began when my father taught me how to fish at the age of ten. I started luremefish.com to share my extensive knowledge of all things fishing.

LEGAL INFORMATION

Luremefish.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Scroll to Top